Some weeks, the hardest part of dinner is deciding what to make. Here are three cozy chicken dinners with very different personalities: a pot of creamy white chili, a squash-and-rice casserole, and salsa chicken that lets everyone build their own plate. One grocery list takes care of the planning.
A shopping note: I prefer organic tortillas for the optional taco-night extras. Read the labels on the salsa, broth, and seasoning blends for added colors or flavorings you prefer to avoid.
See the dinner plan · Jump to the grocery list · Get the prep plan
Three dinners, a little less deciding
This list makes one full batch of each recipe: about 8 servings of White Chicken Chili, 6 servings of the casserole, and 6 servings of salsa chicken before tortillas, rice, or toppings. These are three meal options with potential leftovers, not a promise of three identical-size dinners. Adjust for your household and appetite.
Dinner 1: White Chicken Chili

White beans, green chiles, and cooked chicken make a generous pot of comfort food. Mashing some of the beans gives it a creamy texture, then Monterey Jack goes on top. Keep the cayenne gentle if that suits your table and let the heat-lovers add their own kick.
Allow about 50 minutes with the chicken already cooked. Set the fresh toppings out separately so leftovers are easy to pack. A ladle and portion-size freezer trays from Fall Favorites are useful for serving and saving the extra.
Dinner 2: Chicken, Butternut Squash & Rice Casserole

This is the oven dinner for a night when you have a little more time: cooked chicken, cubes of butternut squash, tomatoes, and rice all tucked into a deep 9×13 pan. The rice cooks in the broth, so use regular long-grain white rice and keep the foil cover tight.
Allow about 85–100 minutes, including the rest. The recipe has checks for rice tenderness and center temperature, since pans and ovens vary. Chop the vegetables ahead, but keep the rice and broth separate until it is time to assemble. The Sourdough Tools collection includes the bench scraper I link in the recipe for moving chopped squash off the board.
Make the Chicken, Squash & Rice Casserole →
Dinner 3: Slow-Cooker Salsa Chicken

Choose mild or medium salsa, add the chicken and seasonings, and finish with fresh lime. Serve the shredded chicken in tortillas or over rice, then let everyone choose the toppings. Tacos tonight, a bowl for lunch tomorrow—that is the kind of repeat I can get behind.
Plan for roughly 5–6 hours on LOW or 3–4 hours on HIGH. Start with fully thawed chicken thighs, follow the appliance instructions, and check for 165°F before shredding. For serving ideas and kitchen basics, browse Everyday Cooking.
Make Slow-Cooker Salsa Chicken →
One grocery list for all three dinners
Quantities below cover one batch of each linked recipe. Check what you have before shopping. The cooked chicken for chili and casserole is separate from the raw thighs for salsa chicken; do not count the same chicken twice.
One-page printable checklist with quantities for all three dinners.
Chicken
- For the chili: 4 cooked boneless chicken breast halves, chopped.
- For the casserole: 2½ cups cooked chicken, in bite-size pieces, in addition to the chicken for the chili.
- For the slow cooker: 2 pounds raw boneless, skinless chicken thighs; thaw fully before cooking.
Produce
- Yellow onions: 1 large, 1 medium, and 1 small. Use the large onion for chili, half the medium onion for the casserole, and the small onion for salsa chicken.
- Garlic: 5 cloves total (3 for chili; 2 for casserole), or ⅝ teaspoon garlic powder total (⅜ teaspoon for chili; ¼ teaspoon for casserole), in addition to the salsa chicken’s garlic powder.
- Butternut squash: enough for 3 cups peeled, ½-inch cubes. Pre-cut squash is fine; cut large pieces smaller.
- Lime: enough for 1 tablespoon fresh juice for salsa chicken; buy extra only if you want lime wedges at the table.
Cans, jars & grains
- Great Northern beans: five 14.5-ounce cans, drained and rinsed, for the chili.
- Green chiles: two 4-ounce cans for the chili; choose mild if preferred.
- Diced tomatoes: one 14.5-ounce can for the casserole; drain well.
- Tomato salsa: 2 cups mild or medium for the slow cooker.
- Chicken broth: three 14.5-ounce cans for chili, plus 3 cups low-sodium broth for the casserole. Have a little extra for adjusting the texture. If buying cartons, three 32-fluid-ounce cartons provide enough for both recipes plus extra.
- Long-grain white rice: 1½ cups uncooked for the casserole. Any rice served with salsa chicken is additional; instant or brown rice is not a direct swap in this casserole.
Dairy
- Monterey Jack: 1 cup shredded for the chili.
Check the pantry first
- Olive oil: 3 tablespoons total, plus a little for greasing the casserole dish.
- Ground cumin: 3 teaspoons total (2 for chili; 1 for salsa chicken).
- Dried oregano: 2 teaspoons for chili.
- Cayenne: up to 1 teaspoon for chili; start with ¼ teaspoon or omit for a milder pot.
- Italian seasoning: 1 teaspoon for the casserole.
- Chili powder: 1 teaspoon for salsa chicken.
- Garlic powder: ½ teaspoon for salsa chicken.
- Kosher salt: ½ teaspoon for the casserole, adjusted for broth saltiness; taste the salsa chicken before adding any extra.
- Black pepper: ¼ teaspoon for the casserole.
Optional serving extras
- For taco night: tortillas (plan about 2 per person), or enough additional rice for the number of bowls you want.
- For toppings: avocado, cilantro (or 1 teaspoon dried cilantro leaves per 1 tablespoon fresh, stirred into the dish during cooking), jalapeños, extra lime, shredded cabbage, or chopped tomatoes.
- For the casserole: chopped parsley (or 1 teaspoon dried parsley per 1 tablespoon fresh, stirred into the casserole before baking) and a simple green salad, if desired. These extras are not included in the core recipe quantities.
A little prep that actually helps
- Decide when you will cook each dinner. Make the casserole on the evening with oven time, and schedule salsa chicken around the cooking window your slow cooker needs.
- Prepare the vegetables. Chop the chili onion and casserole onion, slice the salsa-chicken onion, and cube the squash. Refrigerate them in labeled containers. Keep raw poultry and its utensils separate from ready-to-eat food.
- Portion the seasonings. Make one small spice portion for each recipe so you are not hunting for the cumin three evenings in a row.
- Keep the cooked chicken on its original clock. Refrigerated cooked chicken generally needs using within 3–4 days of its first cooking. Turning it into another dinner does not start a new storage period. Freeze portions promptly if you will need them later.
- Save toppings for serving. Add avocado, cheese, herbs, and crunchy vegetables after reheating so they keep their texture.
Leftovers: Divide cooked food into shallow containers and refrigerate within 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90°F. Keep at 40°F or below and use within 3–4 days, accounting for any older cooked ingredients. Reheat to 165°F; freeze promptly if you will not use it in that time. See USDA leftover-storage guidance.
Keep the easy dinners coming
Find another idea in Cozy Fall Recipes, or join Dinner Club for the Two Weeks of Easier Dinners guide, with ten full recipes, two weekly plans, and grocery lists.

Leave a Reply